My husband and I went here on a beautiful evening and sat outside. We had a reservation but had to wait a little longer for an outdoor seat - no problem. Our waitress, Lauren F. was the best!! She was attentive, loved every dog that walked by, and friendly. My husband and I shared a seafood chowder (chock full of seafood like lobster, bay scallops, shrimp, and fish - so, so good!) We also had the calamari (loved the sweet chili sauce). Marinara is not listed as a sauce included with the dish, but it was provided upon asking. Finally, we had the surf and turf sandwich which was mind-blowingly good. So much lobster and tender steak. The truffle fries that accompanied it were crispy and tasty!
Overview
If you're ever in Port Jefferson, New York, and find yourself craving a meal that combines fresh seafood and perfectly grilled steaks, Castaways Steak & Seafood is the place to be. Situated right on Main Street, this inviting establishment offers a dining experience that's hard to beat.
The ambiance at Castaways Steak & Seafood sets the tone for a memorable meal. With its cozy, nautical-inspired decor, it evokes a sense of being by the shore, even though you're just steps away from the bustling streets of Port Jefferson. The large windows allow natural light to pour in, making the space feel bright and airy. It's the perfect spot for both a casual dinner with friends or a romantic meal for two. The laid-back atmosphere is complemented by friendly and attentive staff, eager to help you navigate the diverse menu.
Speaking of the menu, Castaways Steak & Seafood offers a remarkable range of options that showcase the best of both worlds: land and sea. Their steaks are always cooked to perfection, whether you opt for a tender filet mignon, a juicy ribeye, or a classic New York strip. Each cut of meat is seasoned just right, ensuring a flavorful bite in every piece. Pair your steak with a side of creamy mashed potatoes or crispy roasted vegetables, and you'll have a meal that hits all the right notes.
For seafood lovers, Castaways Steak & Seafood shines with its selection of fresh catches. From succulent lobster tails to crispy fried calamari, the seafood offerings are nothing short of impressive. The restaurant prides itself on sourcing the best fish and shellfish, ensuring each dish is as fresh as it is delicious. One standout dish is the seared scallops, perfectly browned on the outside while maintaining a tender, melt-in-your-mouth interior. The seafood pasta, tossed in a rich garlic butter sauce, is another crowd favorite, packed with flavor and generously portioned.
What truly sets this restaurant apart, though, is the commitment to quality and attention to detail. Each dish is carefully prepared, and the ingredients are top-notch. Whether you're having a simple shrimp cocktail or a complex surf-and-turf entrΓ©e, you can taste the difference in every bite. This dedication to quality is evident not only in the food but also in the presentation, as each dish arrives at the table looking as good as it tastes.
A visit to Castaways Steak & Seafood wouldnβt be complete without exploring their drink offerings. The bar boasts a variety of craft beers, wines, and signature cocktails, perfect for complementing your meal. Whether you're in the mood for a crisp white wine to pair with seafood or a bold red to go with your steak, the staff is happy to make recommendations based on your preferences.
While many diners rave about the food, the overall experience at Castaways Steak & Seafood is what brings people back time and time again. Itβs not just a meal; itβs an experience that blends excellent food, welcoming service, and a cozy atmosphere. The combination of flavors, the fresh ingredients, and the attention to detail make this restaurant a standout in Port Jefferson.
So, if you're in the area and craving a meal that balances the best of steak and seafood, Castaways Steak & Seafood is definitely worth a visit. With its wide variety of dishes, top-notch service, and inviting ambiance, it promises a dining experience you'll be talking about long after the meal is over. Whether you're a local or just visiting, it's a must-try spot for anyone who appreciates great food in a friendly, welcoming environment.
Good to know
Service options
β Outdoor seating β Takeaway β Dine-in β DeliveryHighlights
β Fast service β Great beer selection β Great cocktails β Great dessert β Great wine list β Serves local specialtyPopular for
β Lunch β Dinner β Solo diningAccessibility
β Wheelchair-accessible car park β Wheelchair-accessible entrance β Wheelchair-accessible seating β Wheelchair-accessible toiletOfferings
β Alcohol β Beer β Cocktails β Coffee β Comfort food β Happy-hour drinks β Healthy options β Small plates β Spirits β WineDining options
β Brunch β Lunch β Dinner β Catering β Dessert β Seating β Table serviceAmenities
β Bar on site β ToiletAtmosphere
β Casual β Cosy β Trendy β UpmarketCrowd
β Groups β TouristsPlanning
β Dinner reservations recommended β Accepts reservationsPayments
β Credit cards β Debit cards β NFC mobile paymentsChildren
β Good for kids β High chairs β Kids' menuParking
β Free of charge street parking β Free parking lot β Paid parking lotPhotos
1 / 4
Location
Reviews
- No ratings yet 170 reviews
Wonderful dinner in an atmosphere that captures the vibe of maritime Port Jefferson. The wait staff was friendly and attentive. The menu is well rounded and will accommodate most palates. The wine list and cocktails are also well thought out and cover a nice range of type and cost. Castaways also carries Guiness zero and Heineken zero, bothof which are alcohol removed beers, thank you Castaways. Ordered the Peppered Shrimp as an appetizer and it was delicious, had just the right amount of spicy flavor. Mains were chili lime grilled Salmon, fresh flavor and cooked perfectly as ordered, as well as the Fish and Chips, also really fresh flavor and perfectly cooked. If you are looking for indoor / outdoor dining with a beach atmosphere and good food, Castaways is a must try.
We went to lunch. We ordered seafood chowder and lobster bisque to start with. Lobster bisque was delicious. However, the seafood chowder was sour. We then ordered a Maine lobster roll, blacked chicken with pesto and surf and turf sandwich. It was very delicious. The service was excellent. Our waitress always checked on us.
Everytime I come here the service is exceptional service. Chelsea is an experienced bartender who always makes sure you are good and happy. Very polite and professional. Matt and Jess are outstanding managers who make sure everyone is satisfied to their liking. I never had a bad experience here before
This was my 1st time at Castaway. The food was good, a little pricey. The decor was nice & yes, nautical. The chairs were a bit uncomfortable "small" for larger people. Not everyone is small framed. The service was good, but somewhat disappointing at times. The place was empty so, refilling glasses would have been nice. I ordered a cocktail, The Reaper, it sounded delicious and not knowing anything about booze, I had no idea that Carolina Reaper has ghost pepper in it and I am allergic to pepper. There was no indication on the menu that this was a spicy or pepper related drink. Thank God the waitress mentioned something and I had to send the drink back. They charged us for it but it would have been nice not to be. All in all, it was a nice place, good food but nothing for me says or aches to want to go back.
Chelsea shows professional and exceptional service. Jess and Matt always make sure you are treated right. The chef came out from the back to ask how everything was. The service here is outstanding. Food is beyond expectations
Luxury experience close to the ferry. The local caught stripped bass was a treat and the filet stood tall and had a rare center; as ordered. Can't wait to go again :)