Castaways Steak & Seafood Menu
Starters
New Zealand Baby Lamb Chops
$
Oysters Rockefeller
$
Mussels
$
Yellowfin Tuna Tartar
$
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
$
Peppered Shrimp
$
Grilled Octopus
US$22.00
Steak Sliders
US$22.00
Tuna Pizza
US$26.00
From The Sea
Salmon
$
Chilean Sea Bass
US$41.00
Seafood Fra Diavolo
US$41.00
Mahi Mahi
US$39.00
Sesame & Wasabi Crusted Tuna
US$42.00
Crab Spaghetti
$
Fish & Chips
US$28.00
Handhelds
Blackened Salmon Sandwich
US$20.00
Surf & Turf Sandwich
US$29.00
Castaways Burger
US$23.00
New England Lobster Roll
$
Soups & Salads
Lobster Bisque
$
Seafood Chowder
$
Soup Of The Day
$
Castaways Salad
$
House Salad
$
Caesar Salad
$
Wedge Salad
US$16.00
Poached Pear & Kale Salad
US$18.00
Tnt Salad
US$25.00
Sides
Parmesan Truffle Salt Fries
US$13.00
Creamed Spinach
US$15.00
Lobster Mac
US$25.00
Coconut Rice
US$12.00
Burnt Broccolini
US$13.00
Asparagus
US$13.00
Baked Potato
US$11.00
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
US$12.00
Fried Brussels
US$15.00
From The Land
Filet
US$76.00
Petit Filet
US$61.00
Usda Prime Dry Aged Cowboy Ribeye
US$70.00
New York Strip
US$66.00
Porterhouse For Two
$
Pork Chop
US$36.00
Chicken
US$32.00
Blackened Chicken Pesto Pasta
US$28.00
Raw Bar
Colossal Shrimp Cocktail
US$26.00
Seafood Tasting For Two
$
Seafood Tasting For Four
$
Seafood Tasting For Six
$
Local Little Neck Clams On ½ Shell
US$14.00
Oysters On ½ Shell
US$18.00
Mains
Shrimp Po Boy
US$21.00
Blackened Chicken Pesto Pasta
US$28.00
Blackened Salmon Sandwich
US$20.00
Crab Cake Sandwich
US$24.00
Island Reuben
US$20.00
Lobster Grilled Cheese
US$20.00
Chicken Sandwich
US$20.00
Surf & Turf Sandwich
US$29.00
Castaways Burger
US$23.00
New England Lobster Roll
$
For The Table
Bottomless Mimosas
$
32 Oz Bloody Mary Pitcher
US$33.00
Cup Of Bacon
US$8.00
Drinks
Mixed Drinks
$
Martinis
$
Food
Raw Oysters
US$1.50
Mussels
$
Calamari
US$10.00
Spinach Artichoke Dip
$
Steak Sliders
US$10.00
Mexican Street Corn Dip
$
Chicken Nachos
$
Lobster Bisque
US$10.00
Giant Pretzel W/ Beer Cheese
US$10.00
Loaded Potato Wedges
$
Cocktails
The Pumpkin Press
$
Chocolate Truffle
$
Funky Monkey
$
Vodka
Grey Goose
US$13.00
Ketel One
US$13.00
Ketel Peach & Orange Blossom
US$13.00
Ketel Grapefruit & Rose
US$13.00
Ketel Citron
US$13.00
Broken Shed
US$13.00
Stoli Blueberry
US$11.00
Stoli O
US$11.00
Stoli Raspberry
US$11.00
Stoli Vanilla
US$11.00
Belvedere
US$14.00
Crop Cucumber
US$11.00
Gin
Beefeater
US$11.00
Bombay Sapphire
US$11.00
Empress 1908
$
Hendricks
$
Tanqueray
$
Roku
US$1.00
Dessert Menu
Brownie Sundae
US$13.00
Coconut Flan
US$12.00
Creme Brûlée
US$12.00
Chocolate Bundt Cake
US$13.00
Key Lime Tart
US$14.00
After Dinner Drinks
The Pumpkin Press
$
Chocolate Truffle
$
Funky Monkey
$
Tried & True
$
Cocktail Menu
Tranquiltea
$
Sandy Dollar
$
Hidden Oasis
$
Cast Off
$
Chai Cabrera
$
Corn Hub
$
Monurikey
$
Eiffel 65
$
The Jimmy T
$
Grim Reaper
$
Rye
Angels Envy Rye
US$16.00
Basil Hayden Dark Rye
US$14.00
Basil Hayden Malted Rye
US$14.00
Michters Rye
US$16.00
Whistle Pig 10yr
US$14.00
Widow Jane Rye
US$13.00
Whites
Caposaldo Delle Venezie Pinot Grigio- Italy
US$12.00
Sonoma Cutrer Chardonnay - Sonoma Coast California
$
Louis Jadot Chardonnay - Cote D'or, France
$
Hei Matau Sauvignon Blanc - Marlborough, New Zealand
$
Jacques Dumont Sauvignon Blanc - Loire Valley, France
$
Black Tower Riesling - Rhein, Germany
$
Martin Codax Albariño - Rias Baixas, Spain
US$12.00
Franco Amaroso Moscato D'asti Piedmont, Italy
$
Rosé/Orange
Chateau Minuty Cotes De Provence Rosé - France
$
Maison Idiart Joie De Vivre Rosé Vin De France
$
The Vice Orange
$
Bubbles
Luca Paretti Prosecco
US$12.00
Chandon Brut - California
$
Rose Regale Sparkling Red
$
Reds
J Vineyards Pinot Noir - Sonoma County California
$
Firesteed Pinot Noir - Willamette Valley, Oregon
$
Isla Pinot Noir - France
$
Bodega Norton 1895 Malbec
$
Masi Campofioran Baby Amarone - Veneto, Italy
$
Chateau Des Gravieres Bordeaux Red Blend - France
$
Montes Alpha Cabernet Sauvignon - Chile
$
St. Francis Cabernet Sauvignon - Sonoma County
$
Others
Colossal Shrimp Cocktail
US$26.00
Seafood Tasting For Two
$
Seafood Tasting For Four
$
Seafood Tasting For Six
$
Oysters On 2 Shell
US$18.00
Calamari
US$20.00
Crab Cakes
US$22.00
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
US$22.00
Jerk Chicken Nachos
US$19.00
Mahi Mahi Tacos
$
Shrimp Tacos
$
Tuna Tacos
$
1.5# Whole Steamed Lobster
$
Breakfast Tacos
US$16.00
Quiche
US$15.00
Brunch Burger
US$25.00
Caribbean Chicken And Waffle
US$16.00
Breakfast Hash
US$18.00
Eggs Your Way
US$15.00
Avocado Toast
US$14.00
Egg Sandwich
US$13.00
Pineapple Upside Down Waffles
US$11.00
The Omelette
US$13.00
Skinny Omelette
US$15.00
Breakfast Quesadilla
US$15.00
Crab Benedicts
US$19.00
Smoked Salmon Benedicts
US$18.00
Açaí Bowl
US$13.00
Tranquiltea
$
Sandy Dollar
$
Hidden Oasis
$
Cast Off
$
Chai Cabrera
$
Corn Hub
$
Monurikey
$
Eiffel 65
$
The Jimmy T
$
Grim Reaper
$
Angels Envy
US$14.00
Basil Hayden
US$17.00
Buffalo Trace
US$14.00
Bulleit
US$14.00
Four Roses Small Batch
US$13.00
Jeffersons Ocean
US$18.00
Knob Creek
US$14.00
Knob Creek 12yr
US$16.00
Maker's Mark
US$14.00
Michter's
US$14.00
Old Grand-Dad Bonded
US$12.00
Rabbithole Dareringer
US$16.00
Rabbithole Heigold
US$17.00
Widow Jane 10yr
US$18.00
Widow Jane Lucky 13
US$37.00
Woodford Reserve
US$16.00
Woodford Double Oaked
US$16.00
Balvenie 12yr
US$18.00
Balvenie Caribbean Cask 14yr
US$23.00
Glenlivet 12
US$16.00
Johnnie Walker Black
US$11.00
Macallan 12yr
US$15.00
Crown Royal
US$13.00
Gentleman Jack
US$11.00
Jack Daniels
US$10.00
Jack Daniels Single Barrel
US$19.00
Jameson
US$11.00
Tullamore Dew
US$13.00
Woodford Reserve Wheat
$
At Castaways Steak & Seafood Menu, you’ll find an array of mouthwatering dishes that combine the best of both land and sea. Located in the heart of Port Jefferson, this cozy spot invites guests to savor tender steaks and fresh seafood in a relaxed, friendly atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for a perfectly grilled steak, a crisp salad, or some of the finest seafood in town, the menu offers something for everyone. You can’t go wrong with classic favorites like juicy ribeye steaks, delicate lobster tails, or the house specialty-grilled seafood platters that will transport you straight to the coast. The menu caters to all tastes, from savory starters to indulgent desserts, with each dish prepared with high-quality ingredients that highlight bold flavors and textures. It's the perfect place to unwind with friends or enjoy a special meal with loved ones.